A Brief History of Down syndrome, Part 5: From Education to Eugenics
The training schools for the developmentally delayed in the middle 1800's were an instant success; although they did not offer a cure, they did show improvements in behaviour, physical prowress and social interactions. Many students were able to develop skills that would ensure a successful return to their loved ones.
Sadly, a post-Civil war poor economy did not allow for many employment opportunities for the developmentally disabled in America, no matter how well trained. Jobs were scarce and there were many new immigrants who were willing to work for low wages. People with disabilities were looked at as burdens and were counted (once again) amongst criminals, prostitutes and vagrants in the census reports.
Not surprisingly, there was a simultaneous increase in the demand for training schools; many of the existing schools expanded and initially served a broader disabled community. However, as time went on, the schools quickly became asylums, providing only rudimentary care for their 'inmates'. By 1875, many US states had started construction on institutions for the developmentally disabled. The leaders of these new institutions were now doctors; 1876 saw the establishment of the Association of Medical Officers of the American Institutions for Idiotic and Feeble-Minded Persons (who would later become the American Association for Mental Retardation, now the American Association of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities or AAIDD). One of the primary purposes of this organization is taken from Article II of their constitution:
"The object of the Association shall be the discussion of all questions relating to the causes, conditions, and statistics of idiocy, and the management, training, and education of idiots and feeble-minded persons; it will also lend its influence to the establishment and fostering of institutions for this purpose."
|How Boys are Taught Simple Manual Labor, Massachusetts School|
for the Feeble-Minded, William A. Webster, circa 1903.
Photo courtesy of the Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum
Both Seguin and Howe, two physicians, educators and advocates for the disabled, foresaw the new direction that the schools were heading to. Instead of presenting the keynote address for a groundbreaking for a new institution in New York, Howe begged them not to open it instead. Regardless, the populations in the institutions continued to rise. There were, on average, 250 people per institution in 1890; that number had doubled by 1905.
Walter E. Fernald, the then president of the American Association on Mental Deficiency, described the institutions as an economic solution to the disabled. In his words, "each hundred dollars invested [in institutions] now saves a thousand [dollars] in the next generation.". Money allocated to the poorhouses and almshouses by the state was already being redirected to the large institutions as well. By the close of the century, the annual cost of housing a person in such a place ranged from $150 to $250 USD. In a generation, the public view towards the differently abled, especially the developmentally delayed, had gone from one of compassion and eduction to fear and segregation. By 1923 there were over 80 "schools", "farms", "hospitals", "institutes" and "academies" for the disabled. With it's inmates no longer welcome in the outside world, these asylums could now say that they were relieving society of a great burden.
Protect Us from the Feeble
As the institutions grew and conditions continued to worsen, the public perception of the disabled and "feeble-minded" continued to decline as well. Such "illnesses" were considered to be moral failings of the person or their parents.
Immigration to North America was at an all time high and by 1900, one in seven Americans was born elsewhere. Fear and suspicion of both immigrants and disabled persons was also growing exponentially; this was only augmented by government actions that segregated and excluded these new Americans, which in turn only reinforced and systematized prejudices. The US Public Health Service classified the following together as one group: "criminals, defectives and delinquents". With this in mind, the Public Health Service, administered the new Binel IQ test to immigrants at Ellis Island. Devised originally by the French psychologist (on behest of his government) Alfred Binet, it was created to quickly identify developmentally delayed children for placement in 'special education'. Even Binet himself felt that case studies were more appropriate, however such assessments were lengthy and costly, especially on the larger numbers of people seeking entrance into such facilities. However, there were three codicils to his test: one, the scores are not to be considered permanent. Two, the scale was to be a rough guide for the identification and aid of developmentally delayed children and, three a low score did not determine an innate incapability on the part of the child. However, these tenets were easily brushed aside and from the testing at Ellis Island, it was determined that "79% of the Italians, 80% of the Hungarians, 83% of the Jews, and 87% of the Russians are feeble-minded.", a conclusion which now, scientifically, legitimized the marginalization and prejudice.
As time went on, the view of the institutions shifted further from education to protection; once again the developmentally and physically disabled had become demonized and the public now needed protection.
The Rise of Eugenics
Much like in centuries past, the uncertainty of the economy and world affairs provided a fertile ground for the reappearance of ideas now known as Social Darwinism and Eugenics. The term "Eugenics" was coined in 1883 in Inquiries into Human Faculty and Its Development, a book written by Sir Francis Galton, cousin to Charles Darwin. The Eugenics movement advocated for the improvement of society through the elimination of certain traits.
Misinformation and propaganda began to circulate, citing supposed immorality and the danger to the future of humankind. Feeble mindedness needed to be controlled, if not cured. The term moral imbecility also included such things as juvenile delinquency, behaviour problems and epilepsy and was regarded as a main cause of societal ills including poverty, alcoholism, prostitution, violence and crime in general. Often, those who committed crimes were portrayed in the newspapers in such a way to suggest developmental delay.
Henry Goddard, a psychiatrist at The Vineland Training School, translated the Binet IQ test into English and made a few adjustments; he developed a category of developmental delay known as "moron", which became synonymous with 'moral imbecile' and reinforced the notion that feeble mindedness and therefore delinquency, was hereditary.
John Harvey Kellogg, the inventor of corn flakes, ran a holistic sanatorium in Battle Creek Michigan. In 1906, he created the Race Betterment Foundation, which would hold Eugenics conferences at the sanitarium in the years to come (1914, 1915 and 1928).
The year 1909 saw the publication of The Eugenics Review, the journal of the Eugenics Education Society in Britain. Galton, who was the honorary president, wrote the foreword.
In his 1910 book, Eugenics, The Science of Human Improvement by Better Breeding, Charles Davenport speaks of the formation of a 'Committee on Eugenics' from the American Breeder's Society including such famous names as himself, David Starr Jordan, botanist Luther Burbank, Alexander Graham Bell, zoologist V. L. Kellogg, Swiss psychiatrist (and future president of the American Psychiatric Association) Adolf Meyer, naturalist J. Arthur Thomson, W. E. Castle, Charles Henderson, Aleš Hrdlička, Herbert J. Webber, C. E. Woodruff, and Frederick A. Woods (who coined the phrase Historiometry). According to Davenport, the "various duties of this Committee may be summed up in the three words: investigation, education and legislation". On the surface, this sounds very philanthropic, however, Davenport later continues on with the following:
"...This three or four percent of our population is a fearful drag on our civilization. Shall we as an intelligent people, proud of our control of nature in other respects, do nothing but vote more taxes or be satisfied with the great gifts and bequests that philanthropists have made for the support of the delinquent, defective and dependent classes? Shall we not rather take the steps that scientific study dictates as necessary and dry up the springs that feed the torrent of defective and degenerate protoplasm?"
"...If only one-half of one percent of the 30 million dollars annually spent on hospitals, 20 millions on insane asylums, 20 millions for almshouses, 13 millions on prisons, and 5 millions on the feeble minded, deaf and blind were spent on the study of the bad germ-plasm that makes necessary the annual expenditure of nearly 100 millions in the care of its produce we might hope to learn just how it is being reproduced and the best way to diminish its further spread."
A "sub-committee on Feeble-Mindedness" was also created; it was "under the chairmanship of Dr. A. F. Rogers, Superintendent of the Minnesota School for Feeble Minded and Colony of Epileptics, and with Dr. H. H. Goddard, Director of the Department of Psychological Research at the New Jersey Training School for Feeble-Minded Boys and Girls." Similar committees were created for other "problems", including "Insanity" (Chaired by Dr. Adolf Meyer), eye defects, deafness, crippled limbs, disease, musculature, etc. The 'main committee' was given the task of obtaining records from American families regarding "the inheritance of characteristics of health, ability and temperament". At the time of publication, only 300 of the 5000 family records forms had been returned to be studied, so it was suggested that "data of this sort might be collected by the national Bureau of Census...".
Davenport, along with Harry Laughlin and financial support from Mrs. E. H. Harriman (the widow of the railroad baron), created the Eugenics Record Office in 1910.
Kallikaks, Morons and the Justification of Sterilization
|The lineages of "Martin Kallikak"|
"...a typical illustration of the mentality of a high-grade feeble-minded person, the moron, the delinquent, the kind of girl or woman who fills our reformatories. They are wayward, they get in all sorts of troubles and difficulties, sexually and otherwise, and yet we have been accustomed to account for their defects on the basis of viciousness, environment or ignorance."
|The caption reads: "Great-grandson of|
"Daddy" Kallikak. This boy is an imbecile
of the Mongolian type"
"There are Kallikak families all about us. They are multiplying at twice the rate of the general population, and not until we recognize this fact, and work on this basis, will we begin to solve [our] social problems."
It also validated the use of segregation in an institutional setting and "...sterilization may be accepted as a makeshift, as a help to solve this problem because the conditions have become so intolerable." Clearly, sterilization was the solution for the time being, until something more permanent could be devised.
The first International Congress of Eugenics was held in London in 1912 (they would be held again in 1921 and 1932) . Attendees of note were Winston Churchill, then the First Lord of the British Admiralty, Chief Justice Lord Alverstone, Lord Balfour and then ambassadors of France, Greece and Norway. In the US, the Galton Society was created in 1918; it further popularized eugenic theories through its newsletter the Eugenical News. Contributors included racist authors Madison Grant and Lothrop Stoddard.
By 1915, many of America's prominent universities were offering courses on eugenics: Brown, Harvard, Columbia and Cornell are among those that taught these theories. This is not surprising given the academic backing of eugenics from such persons as psychologists Edward Thorndike and Leta Hollingworth, as well as psychometricians Carl Brigham and Robert Yerkes. Goddard took his presentation on the road and using lantern slides, warned the masses of the "rising tide of feeble mindedness".
A 1917 movie, entitled "The Black Stork" told the fictional story of a couple that were "ill matched" and as a result, gave birth to a disabled baby. The baby in the movie was "mercifully killed" by starvation by eugenicist Harry J Haiselden, who not only starred in the movie as himself, was in real life was a prominent Chicago physician who refused to give life saving care to "defective" babies. Not only were the dying infants displayed to journalists, but he also documented them publicly in the Hearst Newspapers.
|Photo from the North Carolina State Board of|
Charities and Public Welfare Biennial Report
of the State Board of Charities and Public Welfare,
December 1, 1920 to June 30, 1922
By 1924, the US Congress passed the Immigration Restriction Act, specifically targeting those from Europe and Eastern Europe, the majority of which had been labeled "feeble minded" a decade before. Those who were differently abled with mild to moderate disabilities were now considered morons and part of the "moral menace". As the institutions were overflowing, the superintendents, many of which have been named here as Eugenicists (and promoted the idea of the degenerate moron), 'paroled' the higher functioning patients after sterilizing them. It did not take long however, for lower functioning individuals to also be sterilized, especially those who displayed habits considered to be obscene. The men were forced to undergo vasectomies and the females underwent tubal ligation.
|Photo courtesy of the DNA Learning Center,|
Cold Spring Harbour Laboratory
“It is better for all the world, if instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring for crime or to let them starve for their imbecility, society can prevent those who are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind. The principle that sustains compulsory vaccination is broad enough to cover cutting the Fallopian tubes. Three generations of imbeciles are enough.”
Carrie was sterilized and it was found later that she was, in fact, of normal intelligence, as was her daughter who went on to win awards in school. The entire family tree had been fabricated and her entrance into the institution was surmised to be a cover up of her rape at the hands of a foster-cousin, from which her daughter had originated. Carrie went on to be paroled from the institution, got married and eventually died in 1983 in a nursing home. She was buried next to her daughter Vivian, who had been adopted by Carrie's former foster parents (due to her supposed lack of competence) and died at eight years of age. Buck v. Bell has never been overturned.
By 1928, Eugenics was taught in over 376 courses in the US, which covered approximately 20,000 students. High school science textbooks between 1914 and 1948 presented Eugenics as fact, creating two entire generations that believed in segregation, restriction of immigration and sterilization of the "unfit". Compulsory sterilizations of the developmentally and physically disabled were performed worldwide, including in Canada, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Estonia, Iceland, Panama and the United Kingdom. The Eugenics movement eventually lost scientific credibility, but not before hundreds of thousands of developmentally and physically people had been sterilized in the name of social purity.
[Next time: Extermination]
Buck v. Bell, 274 U.S. 200 (1927) <caselaw.lp.findlaw.com>
Burr Johnson, Kate. North Carolina State Board of Charities and Public Welfare Biennial Report of the State Board of Charities and Public Welfare, December 1, 1920 to June 30, 1922. Raleigh: North Carolina State Board of Charities and Public Welfare, 1922. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The University Library. Web. <http://docsouth.unc.edu/>.
Davenport, C. B. Eugenics, The Science of Human Improvement by Better Breeding. New York: Henry Holt and, 1910. Print.
Goddard, Henery Herbert, The Kallikak Family: A Study of the Heredity of Feeble-Mindedness, (2009). College of Law Faculty Publications. http://digitalarchive.gsu.edu/col_facpub/7
Paralells in Time; A History of Developmental Disabilities, The Minnesota Governor's Council on Developmental Disabilities, 2012.
Proceedings of the Association of Medical Officers of American Institutions for Idiotic and Feebleminded Persons. Vol. 1,2. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott &, 1877. Print.
Selden, Steve. "Social Origins of Eugenics." Social Origins of Eugenics. University of Maryland, n.d. Web. <http://www.eugenicsarchive.org/html/eugenics/essay6text.html>.
[Originally appeared on Down Wit Dat]